Sunday, September 14, 2025

Systems

AVI linked to an essay Magical Systems Thinking about problems with complex systems, which in turn references the book Systemantics by John Gall.

"Systems in general work poorly or not at all."

A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked. A complex system designed from scratch never works and cannot be patched up to make it work. You have to start over with a working simple system.

"Great advances are not produced by systems designed to produce great advances."

"Efficiency Expert. Someone who thinks he knows what a system is or should be doing, and who therefore feels his is in a position to pass judgment on how well the system is doing it. At best a nuisance, at worst a menace."

I have claimed that in computer management, there is a "Conservation of Complexity": e.g. a tool that makes some things easier for 90% of your systems will demand horrible hacks to work with the rest. I've also spoken of myself as a political Godelian--any set of laws and regulations will have situations it does not justly address, and adding new rules creates a new set of failures in an infinite and increasingly unwieldy game of whac-a-mole. John Gall takes the analysis further, and amusingly.

1 comment:

Korora said...

I remember the Foxtrot strips where Mr. Pembrook called in an efficiency expert. A nitpicking b*yaay* who even reprimanded Roger for wasting steps when Roger was trying to shake her off.